In the seminar this week everyone was provided with a photo without context. We have been told not to look up the context of the photo, and to answer some questions provided.
What time period, decade or year do you think this photograph was created in? What visual cues support your choice?
I believe that the photo comes from the 21st century, most likely from the 2010s. I think it’s from this time period due to the decoration of the living room. It looks very modern, especially from the artistic decoration in the background. The clean, white walls also support this idea, as that’s decoration fashion trend of the 2000s, while the colours dominated the 1950-60s.
Where in the world was this photograph taken? Again, please detail your reasons for asserting your choice.
I am almost certain this photo was taken in the western half of the world, again due to the fashion trend being utilised in the decoration of the house. While still common in more wealthy households in England, I believe this photo was taken in North America. The household reminds me of one of the houses from Modern Family, which I believe has influenced my decision making regarding this photo. I believe that boxing is more popular in western culture too, however I am not certain of this.
In a short paragraph, how would you describe the key visual elements of the photograph? What is contained within the frame?
The key visual element of the photo is the two boys boxing in the centre. They seem very engaged in their activity, not acknowledging the camera. I would argue that the boy on the left is more of a focus on than boy on the right, due to the fact the boy on the left is closer to the centre while the boy on the right has his back towards the camera. However there is more to the photo than just these two boys. On the left you have the sofas, fireplace and plant, which suggests that the room is a living room. Behind the sofas is three shelves filled with art. This would suggest that the owners of the house are quite cultured.
How is/are the human subject(s) of the photograph engaging with the camera/photographer?
The two human subjects of the photograph are not actively engaging with the photographer or camera. They are both too engaged with their activity, with the boy on the right even having his back towards the camera.
What, if any directions do you think the photographer may have given to the subject(s) of the photograph?
I think the photographer definitely gave a lot of directions to the both of the boys. I imagine he had them stand on the right to fill the empty space, and told the boy on the left to punch while he likely told the boy on the right to face away from the camera.
What do you believe the photographer wants, you, the viewer to take from the image?
I don’t believe that there is a definitive meaning to this photograph, but that instead the photographer wants it to be open to interpretation. In my opinion the story behind the photograph seems to be that the two boys are fighting in the living room while their parents aren’t home. It doesn’t seem like they’re fighting because they’re angry at one another, but more in a sport like fashion. It looks like disaster is about to strike however as the twos boys’ recklessness could cause an accident, especially with the painting behind the boy on the right. The room is very tidy, which would insinuate any mess caused would be very noticeable.
